Not Logged In Log In   Sign Up   Points Leaders
Follow Us    5:30 AM

Message Forum - Read Message

Category: US politics > Topics Add to favorite topics   Post new topicPost New Topic
Author Topic: Do you agree with those that believe we should create a path to citizenship (amnesty) for ILLEGALS? Back to Topics
101Speedster

Champion Author
Ventura

Posts:31,774
Points:2,897,030
Joined:May 2005
Message Posted: Jan 29, 2013 5:36:14 PM

Do you agree with those that believe the United States should create a path to citizenship (amnesty) for anyone in this world that has decided to break our laws, enter into our country (often ILLEGALLY), live here ILLEGALLY, and often work here ILLEGALLY? I left out vote ILLEGALLY and collect benefits that are supposed to be for United States citizens. Nor did I mention the number of ILLEGAL aliens that are locked up in our prisons and jails or the number of people that they have killed while here.

In 1986, amnesty was given to approximately 2 million ILLEGAL aliens. That deal invited another 11 million ILLEGALS into our country. No one knows for sure how many ILLEGALS are living in our country because many in our government do not want them counted and prevent us from doing so. Part of that 1986 amnesty deal included a provision that our borders had to be secured so that more ILLEGAL aliens would not enter our country. There was also supposed to be interior enforcement of our immigration laws. Neither one of those things has yet happened.

There are reasons why countries have immigration laws. Considering the fiscal cliffs that we are now facing in this country, we should not even be considering inviting more of the world's poor into this country.

Giving amnesty to those that have had no respect for the laws of this country would only be rewarding them for breaking our laws, putting them at the front of the line, and be a slap in the face to those people in this world that are trying to legally enter, live, and work in this country.
REPLIES (newest first) Post a Reply
Profile Pic
rjhenn
Champion Author Des Moines

Posts:29,901
Points:2,974,670
Joined:Aug 2005
Message Posted: Apr 4, 2015 8:23:06 PM

I75at7AM - "The numbers could be adjusted each year or two (provide for that in legislation, with oversight and review) based on how the economy is performing, and the unemployment rates."

That would certainly be a necessary part of any such program, though it might be a bit difficult to determine the exact criteria needed.
Profile Pic
nstrdnvstr
Champion Author Twin Cities

Posts:41,996
Points:4,824,935
Joined:May 2001
Message Posted: Apr 4, 2015 8:04:49 PM

rjhenn,I agree with most of your last post. However I think that those born here regardless of parents should be citizens. That doesn't mean that they should be anchor babies. If their parents are here illegally, they should not just be able to stay because their kid is a citizen. They could have a choice of leaving their child(ren) with a legal relative or take them back to their native country with them. Their choice. Thus no one is forcing them to leave their children.

I also believe that those that are here illegally should not be rewarded with citizenship. They should eventually, if they meet conditions, get legal status, but that is as far as I would go. People that do things the right, legal way should be the ones getting citizenship, not the ones that break the law either coming over legally or overstaying their visa.
Profile Pic
I75at7AM
Champion Author Dayton

Posts:75,949
Points:3,291,660
Joined:Feb 2006
Message Posted: Apr 4, 2015 7:32:37 PM

Rj., we disagree sometimes, we agree sometimes, and I need to clearly point out that I am in agreement with every point you made in your last post!

The temporary worker visa program certainly needs to be revamped. The numbers could be adjusted each year or two (provide for that in legislation, with oversight and review) based on how the economy is performing, and the unemployment rates.
Profile Pic
rjhenn
Champion Author Des Moines

Posts:29,901
Points:2,974,670
Joined:Aug 2005
Message Posted: Apr 4, 2015 4:11:56 PM

My position and ideas on illegal immigration haven't changed much: Go after the employers (Sell green cards for $50,000 cash a pop, and make the penalty for hiring an illegal paying for his green card, Now. In cash); redesign the visa system, including adding a limited number of temp worker visas that would first go to those already here, with stable jobs and no criminal record; restrict welfare to citizens and permanent resident aliens; reinterpret the 14th so that only those born here to parents who are here both legally and permanently are citizens by birth;have a fast track to citizenship for those immigrants who serve honorably in our armed forces, no quotas for that though (when I enlisted, Congress was requiring that the services take a certain number/percentage (not sure which) of people who didn't meet minimum standards. There was a whole separate part of basic, called 'proficiency',where they tried to bring them up to minimum educational standards).
Profile Pic
johnnyg1200
Champion Author St. Louis

Posts:9,818
Points:1,531,020
Joined:May 2011
Message Posted: Apr 2, 2015 8:30:29 PM

At the same time we are being invaded by illegal aliens the U.S Supreme Court ruled that schools have the right to ban shirts with the American flag if there is reason to believe it will offend some people on Cinco De Mayo.

Why are we in this had basket and where are we going?
Profile Pic
mnrick041
Champion Author Twin Cities

Posts:18,657
Points:2,264,190
Joined:Jun 2009
Message Posted: Apr 2, 2015 6:48:38 PM

My answer is still NO.
Profile Pic
I75at7AM
Champion Author Dayton

Posts:75,949
Points:3,291,660
Joined:Feb 2006
Message Posted: Apr 2, 2015 12:39:45 PM

Much has been made of the situation at the border, with UAC's (unaccompanied alien children) making the arduous and dangerous journey northward and having to deal with human traffickers, narco-terrorists, trigger-happy border guards, and the occasional surly rancher, as they gain their prize of entry into the USA (Los Estados Unidos).

In an effort to defuse that "crisis", the DHS has come up with a new program. Just send the future refugees a plane ticket to the US, and have all their government benefits ready and waiting when they get here!

DHS Launches “Family Reunification,” Refugee Program for Central Americans

"To facilitate the often treacherous process of entering the United States illegally through the southern border, the Obama administration is offering free transportation from three Central American countries and a special refugee/parole program with “resettlement assistance” and permanent residency."

"Specifically, the “program provides certain children in El Salvador, Guatemala and Honduras with a safe, legal, and orderly alternative to the dangerous journey that some children are undertaking to the United States,” according to a DHS memo obtained by JW this week."

" A State Department official promoted CAM as a “family reunification” program that will be completely funded by American taxpayers, though the official claimed to have no idea what the cost will be."

No surprise there, that part about not knowing what the cost will be.

How many are coming?

"The State Department official assured that applicants need not express or document a credible fear to qualify under CAM because “we want to make sure this program is open to as many people as possible.”"

Related:

Communities have little say about the amount of refugees they receive

"The federal resettlement program began 35 years ago, and today includes some 190 sites across the country."

"The city of Concord (New Hampshire) has minimal say, and minimal official responsibilities, over refugee resettlement."

"City employees – who work in public assistance programs, public safety or otherwise – provide help to individual refugees as needed."

"“We just do what we normally do for anybody else that comes in,” said Jacqueline Whatmough, the city’s human services director."

Resettlement:
"before a refugee ever sets foot on U.S. soil, there are months – and more often years – of work and planning to complete. Each part of the process has been meticulously designed – from the initial screening to the plane ride here to the 200-plus-page welcome guide summarizing life in this country – and depends on various public and private entities working in unison across state and international lines."

"Once here, resettlement agencies cover rent and basic living expenses for the first month. Some newcomers qualify for an early employment program, which extends the period of assistance to six months. They are also allowed to apply for public benefits, such as food stamps."

Welcome to America, the land of Free Everything, brought to you by the American Taxpayers!



[Edited by: I75at7AM at 4/2/2015 12:41:50 PM EST]
Profile Pic
nstrdnvstr
Champion Author Twin Cities

Posts:41,996
Points:4,824,935
Joined:May 2001
Message Posted: Mar 15, 2015 6:49:17 AM

Middletownmarty, ""So why should those that are here illegally ever get citizenship?"

Why should you (or any natural born Americans) have received citizenship simply by virtue of being born here?"

Because that is how it works in just about EVERY COUNTRY!

That is what it says in the US Constitution!

We have rules and laws that need to be followed.

They knowingly and willingly broke the law and should suffer consequences for it. Rewarding people for bad behavior is JUST BAD POLICY!!!

Profile Pic
nstrdnvstr
Champion Author Twin Cities

Posts:41,996
Points:4,824,935
Joined:May 2001
Message Posted: Mar 15, 2015 6:44:50 AM

Middletownmarty, ""Those who choose to break our laws on how to become a citizen have no rights under our laws "

That's not true."

You are correct, but they shouldn't have a right to become a US citizen, especially ahead of other people who are coming over here and doing things the right and legal way.

What is wrong with eventually just giving them legal status without citizenship?

They broke and are breaking the law staying here illegally. They have no right to automatic citizenship.
Profile Pic
wbacon
Champion Author Philadelphia

Posts:16,948
Points:3,825,905
Joined:Jun 2004
Message Posted: Mar 15, 2015 4:56:55 AM

no
Profile Pic
BlkynB
Champion Author San Diego

Posts:28,389
Points:3,305,305
Joined:Feb 2006
Message Posted: Mar 15, 2015 3:12:08 AM

We already have a path for legal citizenship that many generations have followed, and it is still in force.

We don'[t need a path to take lawbreakers and make them citizens -- PERIOD.

.
Profile Pic
MiddletownMarty
Champion Author Connecticut

Posts:24,119
Points:347,045
Joined:Jul 2008
Message Posted: Mar 14, 2015 6:28:56 PM

"We have a procedure to legally enter the United States and become a full citizen of this country"

That procedure, for natural born citizens, is to enter the US via the birth canal. None of us did a thing to earn citizenship, let alone the overcome the hurdles we insist on potential naturalized citizens to overcome. I wonder how many of us could endure them.



"Those who choose to break our laws on how to become a citizen have no rights under our laws "

That's not true. Funny how you tout the law in the first part of your post and later ignore it when it suits.

[Edited by: MiddletownMarty at 3/14/2015 6:29:20 PM EST]
Profile Pic
flyboyUT
Champion Author Utah

Posts:30,493
Points:1,745,190
Joined:Aug 2008
Message Posted: Mar 14, 2015 5:36:59 PM

"Why should you (or any natural born Americans) have received citizenship simply by virtue of being born here?" Maybe because thats what our laws say ya think.....

What does the term Illegal Alien mean - try someone who is not here legally and needs to be held accountable for breaking our laws and should be deported at the earliest opportunity and returned whence they came from.

We have a procedure to legally enter the United States and become a full citizen of this country. Those who choose to break our laws on how to become a citizen have no rights under our laws - they need to be removed from our society ASAP.

I would like to see a massive fine for any company hiring an illegal alien to work here in the US. If it no longer became profitable for companies to hire them they would self deport as they could not work and would not be eligible for taxpayer paid aid of any kind. Any emergency aid would be a bill sent to their home country and if not paid the country would receive less aid from us.
Profile Pic
MiddletownMarty
Champion Author Connecticut

Posts:24,119
Points:347,045
Joined:Jul 2008
Message Posted: Mar 14, 2015 5:21:51 PM

"The democrat party's message on the illegal aliens issue is simply more effective and appealing. "

More effective and appealing than the republican message of self-sufficiency and opportunity for all, or more believable?



"If amnesty did not include a path to voting citizenship it would sail through the congress."

That Congress won't wrestle with difficult issues doesn't say much about Congress' ability to govern.


Profile Pic
therder
Champion Author Lexington

Posts:4,589
Points:2,490,270
Joined:Feb 2007
Message Posted: Mar 13, 2015 10:40:22 PM

>>Why do you suppose they wouldn't vote for Republicans? I wonder if it might be some embedded message the Republicans are sending that would turn them off to the Republican dream of self-sufficiency and opportunity.<<
The democrat party's message on the illegal aliens issue is simply more effective and appealing. It's much easier for democrats to continue pandering for votes in their growing hispanic base. Democrats know that demographics and time are on their side. In contrast, the republican party is trying to be "democrat lite" on the issue and exposing the fractures in their party.

If amnesty did not include a path to voting citizenship it would sail through the congress.
Profile Pic
MiddletownMarty
Champion Author Connecticut

Posts:24,119
Points:347,045
Joined:Jul 2008
Message Posted: Mar 13, 2015 6:22:20 PM

"So why should those that are here illegally ever get citizenship?"

Why should you (or any natural born Americans) have received citizenship simply by virtue of being born here?



"Because only making them U.S. Nationals without also granting citizenship won't allow them to vote (for democrats) in elections."

Why do you suppose they wouldn't vote for Republicans? I wonder if it might be some embedded message the Republicans are sending that would turn them off to the Republican dream of self-sufficiency and opportunity.

[Edited by: MiddletownMarty at 3/13/2015 6:22:43 PM EST]
Profile Pic
therder
Champion Author Lexington

Posts:4,589
Points:2,490,270
Joined:Feb 2007
Message Posted: Mar 13, 2015 5:56:00 PM

>>So why should those that are here illegally ever get citizenship? What is wrong with just eventually giving them legal status without citizenship?<<

Because only making them U.S. Nationals without also granting citizenship won't allow them to vote (for democrats) in elections.
Profile Pic
nstrdnvstr
Champion Author Twin Cities

Posts:41,996
Points:4,824,935
Joined:May 2001
Message Posted: Mar 13, 2015 4:47:07 PM

So why should those that are here illegally ever get citizenship? What is wrong with just eventually giving them legal status without citizenship?
Profile Pic
I75at7AM
Champion Author Dayton

Posts:75,949
Points:3,291,660
Joined:Feb 2006
Message Posted: Mar 13, 2015 11:46:42 AM

From the AP:

15 immigrants protected from deportation arrested in sweep

" The Associated Press

WASHINGTON —

Federal agents in a sweep targeting the most dangerous criminal immigrants arrested 15 people who have been allowed to remain in the U.S. under President Barack Obama's executive action intended to protect children who came to the U.S. years ago with their parents, The Associated Press has learned."

"Fourteen of the 15 had been convicted of a crime, the Homeland Security Department confirmed late Thursday."

"One of the eligibility requirements for the program is that immigrants not have a criminal history."

"ICE agents arrested 2,059 convicted immigrants, including more than 1,000 people who had multiple convictions"

Okay, 2,059 arrested, 15 had been issued protection under the new Amnesty directive. That's a really small percentage, right? A really small number? Meaningless, unless one of these criminal aliens committed a crime against you or a loved one....

[Edited by: I75at7AM at 3/13/2015 11:49:22 AM EST]
Profile Pic
I75at7AM
Champion Author Dayton

Posts:75,949
Points:3,291,660
Joined:Feb 2006
Message Posted: Mar 5, 2015 12:36:39 PM

As the writer here says, this will make your blood run cold, and make your rage run hot:

0bama Amnesty Plan: Legalize Foreigners, 'Take Over the Host,' 'Push Citizens into the Shadows'

"It was supposed to be a phone call for Obama administration ears only. But hear it the radio host did, she says."

"0bama’s amnesty plan is to use illegal aliens as “seedlings,” said the federal officials. They will “navigate, not assimilate,” as they “take over the host,” create a “country within a country” and start “pushing the citizens into the shadows.”"

"Welcome to the “fundamental transformation” of America."

"The above was alleged by WCBM radio co-host Sue Payne in an interview with talk giant Mark Levin Thursday last week."

"To this nefarious end, the goal of the TFNA is to create a “welcoming feeling” in illegal-seeded localities, which would be redesignated “receiving communities.” They’d subsequently be transformed (fundamentally, I suppose) into what are labeled “emerging immigrant communities” — or as some would say, México Norte."

"The officials also said, reports Payne, that for the seedlings to “grow” they needed “fertile soil” (a.k.a. your tax money). The officials stated that the legalized aliens needed to be redesignated as “refugees” and be given cash, medical care, credit cards for purchasing documents and — since many illegals will be older — Social Security..."

Welcome, indeed, to Lord 0bama's transformed America.

Shut up and pay your damned taxes (just raised by $100 Billion by a phone call). You can't speak out or you will be labelled a 'racist' and the government might clamp down on your business (if you have one) through Operation Choke Point.

Yeah, they've got it covered.

I hope you like what you have done to America. Only idiots voted for that guy.
Profile Pic
e_jeepin
Champion Author Michigan

Posts:4,973
Points:144,230
Joined:May 2007
Message Posted: Feb 26, 2015 12:36:50 PM

Booting them out is not a reasonable solution because the majority of them likely have been here for a very long time. They operate in the gray market fringes, cash, no taxes.

I'm all for amnesty if you want to become a citizen. However, it absolutely cannot be an express lane to voting.

Make no mistake, Obama wants these people to vote in 2016.

1. You have 6 months to surrender yourself, and register
2. If you are working -- GREAT! now pay taxes
3. Streamline the citizenship path cutting attorneys out
4. Pass basic language test
5. Health standards met
6. Criminals need not apply
7. Pass a formal driving program
8. Pass existing citizenship testing

Yes it will take a few years, and shouldn't suck you dry in attorney fees.

Why is this so difficult? Because Democrats want voters first, nothing else matters. If this happens, our country implodes -- overwhelmed in a free-for-all that sinks Citizens that are already here LEGALLY.


[Edited by: e_jeepin at 2/26/2015 12:42:24 PM EST]
Profile Pic
klutz347
Champion Author Michigan

Posts:1,690
Points:446,545
Joined:Feb 2005
Message Posted: Feb 26, 2015 11:48:49 AM

No.

If you want to become a citizen of this country, we have ways to do it. Do it properly, welcome to our great country.

If you come here ILLEGALLY, expect to be booted out until you can come back and do it the way we tell you too.

Profile Pic
I75at7AM
Champion Author Dayton

Posts:75,949
Points:3,291,660
Joined:Feb 2006
Message Posted: Feb 26, 2015 11:44:44 AM

0bama: 'Consequences' for ICE 0fficials Who Don't Follow Executive Amnesty

"President Obama warned workers at the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement: implement executive amnesty, or else. He made the comments in a town hall event on immigration on MSNBC." (Chances are you did not see it)

"According to the White House pool report, President 0bama was asked for reassurance that people wouldn't be deported as the legal battle over the executive amnesty plays out in the courts."

“Until we pass a law through Congress, the executive actions we’ve taken are not going to be permanent; they are temporary. There are going to be some jurisdictions and there may be individual ICE official or Border Control agent not paying attention to our new directives. But they’re going to be answerable to the head of Homeland Security because he’s been very clear about what our priorities will be,” 0bama said, according to a partial transcript provided by the pool reporter."

"“If somebody’s working for ICE … and they don’t follow the policy, there’s going to be consequences to it.”"

So he's using the phone, the pen, and the Teleprompter.

[Edited by: I75at7AM at 2/26/2015 11:47:03 AM EST]
Profile Pic
I75at7AM
Champion Author Dayton

Posts:75,949
Points:3,291,660
Joined:Feb 2006
Message Posted: Feb 12, 2015 11:18:39 AM

The free money buzzer is ringing again, BIGTIME !!!

IRS to pay back-refunds to illegal immigrants who didn’t pay taxes

"IRS Commissioner John Koskinen told Congress on Wednesday that even illegal immigrants who didn’t pay taxes will be able to claim back-refunds once they get Social Security numbers under President Obama’s temporary deportation amnesty.

The revelation — which contradicts what he told Congress last week — comes as lawmakers also raised concerns Mr. Obama’s amnesty could open a window to illegal immigrants finding ways to vote, despite it being against the law."

Congress needs to pass a bill, immediately, to address this incongruity. The bill should clearly state that non-citizens are not "entitled" to refunds of money that they did not pay in taxes. Congress also should not allow regular Social Security numbers to be issued to illegals or other legal aliens. Those persons should be issued a TIN that is of a different format than a Social Security Number, so that the privileges of citizenship are not conferred on people who aren't eligible for it.



[Edited by: I75at7AM at 2/12/2015 11:19:44 AM EST]
Profile Pic
flyboyUT
Champion Author Utah

Posts:30,493
Points:1,745,190
Joined:Aug 2008
Message Posted: Feb 6, 2015 5:39:04 PM

The only path for Illegal Aliens should be the way out!
Profile Pic
I75at7AM
Champion Author Dayton

Posts:75,949
Points:3,291,660
Joined:Feb 2006
Message Posted: Feb 6, 2015 4:02:16 PM

When the free money buzzer rings, the line to get into this country gets really long. Except that there is no line, just come on in, any ol' place or any ol' way, and start enjoying the good life in the USA.

Ask any illegal alien you happen to meet, "Did you get your Amnesty Bonus?"

Or maybe, don't mention it at all.....

Congress needs to address this situation with a simple, 2-part law:
1. EITC can be claimed only by citizens.
2. EITC cannot be applied retroactively.
Profile Pic
I75at7AM
Champion Author Dayton

Posts:75,949
Points:3,291,660
Joined:Feb 2006
Message Posted: Feb 2, 2015 3:38:06 PM

In case you didn't know this was happening, this might be news:

0bama Quietly Adds 5.46 Million Foreigners To Economy

"President Barack 0bama has quietly handed out an extra 5.46 million work permits for non-immigrant foreigners who arrived as tourists, students, illegal immigrants or other types of migrants since 2009, according to federal documents released by a Freedom of Information Act request.

“The executive branch is operating a huge parallel work-authorization system outside the bounds of the [immigration] laws and limits written by Congress [and which] inevitably reduces job opportunities for Americans,” said Jessica Vaughan, the policy director at the Center for Immigration Studies, while filed the FOIA request."

What's that unemployment rate again? What about jobs that Americans just won't do? (Just ask Loretta Lynch about that).

"“The true magnitude of how often he has evaded the limits set by Congress on foreign workers has never been known until now,” she told The Daily Caller."

The illegal actions by this illegitimate president continue!

[Edited by: I75at7AM at 2/2/2015 3:40:30 PM EST]
Profile Pic
101Speedster
Champion Author Ventura

Posts:31,774
Points:2,897,030
Joined:May 2005
Message Posted: Feb 1, 2015 2:13:08 PM

It doesn't matter what we believe. It's what King Obama wants.
Profile Pic
Tru2psu2
Champion Author Winston-Salem

Posts:18,600
Points:2,345,310
Joined:Feb 2004
Message Posted: Dec 27, 2014 8:22:08 AM

WE already have a process for immigrants!
Profile Pic
therder
Champion Author Lexington

Posts:4,589
Points:2,490,270
Joined:Feb 2007
Message Posted: Dec 27, 2014 12:33:29 AM

The terms "undocumented worker", "undocumented immigrant", "unlawful immigrant", "undocumented alien", "undocumented student", "undocumented migrant", "unauthorized immigrant", and "illegal immigrant" are often used to describe those who have broken the law of our land to enter and work in our country illegally. These are all misleading terms, deliberately used to "soften" the issue of illegal entry into the United States.

The term "undocumented" implies that foreign nationals have the unconditional right to violate America's borders and immigration laws, and that the worst offense they may have committed was forgetting to complete some paperwork. The reality of the situation is the illegal aliens have all kinds of Social Security cards and other documents - it's just that those documents are forged or stolen.

An "immigrant" is an invited guest - a person who comes to a country where they are not a citizen in order to settle there. The term "immigrant" implies permanent, legal, residency. (Although because of amnesties and status adjustments, about 25% of currently legal immigrants first came here illegally).

The accurate description of a foreign national illegally residing in America is "illegal alien". An illegal alien is a criminal.
Profile Pic
SE3.5
Champion Author Indianapolis

Posts:26,591
Points:4,024,865
Joined:May 2004
Message Posted: Dec 2, 2014 12:16:29 PM

"Why do some people have such a hard time understanding the difference between legal immigration and illegal immigration?"

"There are none so blind as those who will not see."

--source debatable
Profile Pic
johnnyg1200
Champion Author St. Louis

Posts:9,818
Points:1,531,020
Joined:May 2011
Message Posted: Dec 2, 2014 12:09:04 PM

<<Send all you descendants of immigrants back to where you came from! They probably won't want you either!<<

Why do some people have such a hard time understanding the difference between legal immigration and illegal immigration? I have no problem with people who come here by following the law. What I have a problem with is the idea of people coming here in violation of the law and then getting benefits I can’t get, in state tuition to Cal Tech for starters.
Profile Pic
johnnyg1200
Champion Author St. Louis

Posts:9,818
Points:1,531,020
Joined:May 2011
Message Posted: Dec 2, 2014 12:05:39 PM

>>We managed to intern about 120,000 Japanese during WWII, not millions. We've got millions of illegals. <<

OOOPs thanks for the correction.
Profile Pic
naw
Champion Author Denver

Posts:4,386
Points:748,720
Joined:Oct 2006
Message Posted: Dec 2, 2014 2:26:51 AM

Send all you descendants of immigrants back to where you came from! They probably won't want you either!


[Edited by: naw at 12/2/2014 2:31:12 AM EST]
Profile Pic
rjhenn
Champion Author Des Moines

Posts:29,901
Points:2,974,670
Joined:Aug 2005
Message Posted: Dec 2, 2014 1:15:19 AM

johnnyg1200 - "We can make it financially unsound to hire and Illegal, jail time sounds good to me."

I like the idea I mentioned earlier. Sell green cards for $50,000 cash a pop, and make the penalty for hiring an illegal paying for his green card. Now.

How many illegals will decide NOT to turn in their employer? My guess is, not many.

"We can make it less attractive to come here illegally, No free anything. No education at resident rates, no food stamps, no free medical care. If they want these things get them at home."

That all sounds good.

"We managed to intern millions of Japans during WW11. I think we can find a way to detain illegals until they can make arrangements to get home."

We managed to intern about 120,000 Japanese during WWII, not millions. We've got millions of illegals.
Profile Pic
johnnyg1200
Champion Author St. Louis

Posts:9,818
Points:1,531,020
Joined:May 2011
Message Posted: Dec 1, 2014 9:29:22 PM

>>>streetrider - "We cannot deport all the illegals."<<<

We can make it financially unsound to hire and Illegal, jail time sounds good to me.

We can make it less attractive to come here illegally, No free anything. No education at resident rates, no food stamps, no free medical care. If they want these things get them at home.

We managed to intern millions of Japans during WW11. I think we can find a way to detain illegals until they can make arrangements to get home.

They have broken the laws of the land and should not be given a free pass much less a reward.
Profile Pic
rjhenn
Champion Author Des Moines

Posts:29,901
Points:2,974,670
Joined:Aug 2005
Message Posted: Dec 1, 2014 4:32:07 PM

I75at7AM - "I consider housing and feeding and providing medical care and providing transportation all across the country to people who don't even deserve to be here to be a waste of money."

And part of my proposal was: "restrict welfare to citizens and permanent resident aliens".
Profile Pic
streetrider
Champion Author Gary

Posts:10,989
Points:157,515
Joined:May 2004
Message Posted: Dec 1, 2014 4:24:22 PM

We need to get these people above ground, issuing work visas does this no visa good by.

Then a path to citizenship?
Profile Pic
I75at7AM
Champion Author Dayton

Posts:75,949
Points:3,291,660
Joined:Feb 2006
Message Posted: Dec 1, 2014 3:50:07 PM

I consider housing and feeding and providing medical care and providing transportation all across the country to people who don't even deserve to be here to be a waste of money.

Build the damn fence!

In areas where the fence was completed, it is effective. (I know, the crossers just head for an area without the new fence). If the fence sows down the torrent to a trickle, we can better direct personnel resources to stopping those who do cross or finding those who overstay visas.
Profile Pic
rjhenn
Champion Author Des Moines

Posts:29,901
Points:2,974,670
Joined:Aug 2005
Message Posted: Dec 1, 2014 2:31:06 PM

I75at7AM - "We can keep out a great number of them with the border fence that was authorized in 2006."

A border fence is a massive waste of effort.

"We can do these things if we try."

We can also waste a ton of money and effort trying to do these things. It's the wrong (meaning expensive and ineffective) approach.
Profile Pic
I75at7AM
Champion Author Dayton

Posts:75,949
Points:3,291,660
Joined:Feb 2006
Message Posted: Dec 1, 2014 9:07:06 AM

>>>We also can't keep out all of the new ones trying to get in.<<<

We can keep out a great number of them with the border fence that was authorized in 2006.

We can keep out a great number of them if they know that, after spending their life savings getting smuggled into the US, we will send them straight back across the border forthwith and they will have nothing to show for it.

We can do these things if we try.
Profile Pic
nstrdnvstr
Champion Author Twin Cities

Posts:41,996
Points:4,824,935
Joined:May 2001
Message Posted: Dec 1, 2014 5:57:15 AM

I agree with you here rjhenn.

And they certainly do not deserve citizenship. Why not eventually let them earn legal status?

[Edited by: nstrdnvstr at 12/1/2014 5:58:19 AM EST]
Profile Pic
rjhenn
Champion Author Des Moines

Posts:29,901
Points:2,974,670
Joined:Aug 2005
Message Posted: Dec 1, 2014 2:36:16 AM

streetrider - "We cannot deport all the illegals."

No, we can't. We also can't keep out all of the new ones trying to get in.

What we can do is make it less attractive to remain here illegally, less attractive to hire illegals, and perhaps help make it more attractive for these people to remain where they are.
Profile Pic
streetrider
Champion Author Gary

Posts:10,989
Points:157,515
Joined:May 2004
Message Posted: Dec 1, 2014 12:01:46 AM

Weather we like it or not, this will get done one way or another it always dose.

We cannot deport all the illegals.

[Edited by: streetrider at 12/1/2014 12:02:10 AM EST]
Profile Pic
SE3.5
Champion Author Indianapolis

Posts:26,591
Points:4,024,865
Joined:May 2004
Message Posted: Nov 29, 2014 9:08:22 AM

Whatever path that is created should begin BEHIND the line where all the prospective legal immigrants are waiting.

Remember the last time you were waiting in line at the bank, or motor vehicles, or some store's cashier, and some ONE tried to cut in? Multiply the "cut in" by a couple of million.
Profile Pic
rjhenn
Champion Author Des Moines

Posts:29,901
Points:2,974,670
Joined:Aug 2005
Message Posted: Nov 29, 2014 3:28:25 AM

flyboyUT - "Why not eliminate all the immigration laws?"

Well, if you think anarchy is a viable system, then there's no reason to have any laws.

OTOH, we don't have the economic room for unlimited immigration that we had in the 19th century.
Profile Pic
rjhenn
Champion Author Des Moines

Posts:29,901
Points:2,974,670
Joined:Aug 2005
Message Posted: Nov 29, 2014 3:23:14 AM

nstrdnvstr - "rjhenn, why should they get citizenship? They knowingly and willingly broke our laws."

Where did I say that they should get citizenship?
Profile Pic
reb4
Champion Author Chicago

Posts:26,470
Points:2,720,890
Joined:Sep 2004
Message Posted: Nov 28, 2014 8:35:34 PM

fly, doubt the libbers will listen, or understand milt... especially the last line...
Profile Pic
flyboyUT
Champion Author Utah

Posts:30,493
Points:1,745,190
Joined:Aug 2008
Message Posted: Nov 28, 2014 3:43:13 PM

Why not eliminate all the immigration laws?
Profile Pic
reb4
Champion Author Chicago

Posts:26,470
Points:2,720,890
Joined:Sep 2004
Message Posted: Nov 28, 2014 9:51:15 AM

fines need to be paid, re-imbursement for services that were rendered to them through tax payer means... and real cost fees should be paid... back taxes should be required as well...
Profile Pic
nstrdnvstr
Champion Author Twin Cities

Posts:41,996
Points:4,824,935
Joined:May 2001
Message Posted: Nov 28, 2014 8:40:26 AM

rjhenn, why should they get citizenship? They knowingly and willingly broke our laws.

Post a reply Back to Topics