Not Logged In Log In   Sign Up   Points Leaders
Follow Us    11:52 PM

Message Forum - Read Message

Category: Car Talk > Topics Add to favorite topics   Post new topicPost New Topic
Author Topic: HD radio worth it? Back to Topics
eccerr0r

Champion Author
Fort Collins

Posts:1,930
Points:1,135,760
Joined:Apr 2011
Message Posted: Jan 25, 2013 12:40:15 PM

Do people have "HD" radio? Do you like it? Is it any better than analog FM?

Does it drop back to analog if the signal can't be decoded for few seconds (though I thought HD radio is broadcast at the same frequency on a side band so likely both would get affected...)?

I wonder if it's worth it to get HD radio or not. My factory radio is starting to get a bit weak on a station that used to come in strongly (and other radios have no problem with the same station so it isn't the station getting weaker)...

I just don't like the fact that HD radio is patent encumbered.
REPLIES (newest first) Post a Reply
Profile Pic
MudNutZ
Champion Author Mississippi

Posts:1,055
Points:1,014,525
Joined:Nov 2010
Message Posted: Feb 5, 2013 9:18:06 AM

to me, no.
Profile Pic
eccerr0r
Champion Author Fort Collins

Posts:1,930
Points:1,135,760
Joined:Apr 2011
Message Posted: Feb 4, 2013 7:41:45 PM

>You must be part of that (IMHO) fringe element that wants to use only patent-free technology while you would certainly object if somebody wanted you to give away the fruits of your labor free of charge. Compact Disc used to be patented (it was a nickel a disc to get rights to all the salient intellectual property rights) but those patents have since expired. However, the Philips "Compact Disc" trademark mark is still licensed as trademarks remain enforceable as long as they're still in use.

Not at all, aren't we allowed to learn how things are made for personal enhancement? This should fall under fair use as it's educational. It would be a totally different issue if someone were to duplicate and start selling cheaper, now that is really underhanded. There is definitely a fine line here of course, but really when radio transmitters are sold, the product is not the transmitter, but the listeners - the CONSUMER listening to the radio, ready to BUY products being advertised over the air...

I actually had no desire to reverse engineer a CD drive, those actually are simple enough to decode, minus the servo and mechanical aspect to keep the disc spinning at a constant rate - now that's the complicated part of CD's. Same goes with DVD's - those are encrypted even, but no desire to decrypt... don't want that crappy content...
Profile Pic
Toonces2013
All-Star Author Illinois

Posts:603
Points:30,980
Joined:Jan 2013
Message Posted: Jan 28, 2013 8:46:31 PM

Yep.
Profile Pic
weddy11
Champion Author Phoenix

Posts:4,405
Points:1,030,750
Joined:Dec 2011
Message Posted: Jan 27, 2013 5:12:48 PM

not to me.
Profile Pic
Sneakers55
Champion Author Houston

Posts:61,915
Points:2,662,420
Joined:Nov 2005
Message Posted: Jan 27, 2013 4:51:35 PM

On Jan 25, 2013 11:40:15 AM, eccerr0r wrote:

>Do people have "HD" radio?

It sounds attractive to me, but as of yet I do not have an HD radio. It will be a long time before I buy my next vehicle unless my current one gets totaled like its immediate predecessor.

>Does it drop back to analog if the signal can't be decoded for few seconds
>(though I thought HD radio is broadcast at the same frequency on a side
>band so likely both would get affected...)?

It can drop back to analog on the HD-1 signal, but not on the HD-2 or HD-3 signal.

>I wonder if it's worth it to get HD radio or not.

It supposedly improves music to CD quality, but then my tin ears find FM quality to be fine and HD does use a proprietary lossy coding method.

>I just don't like the fact that HD radio is patent encumbered.

You must be part of that (IMHO) fringe element that wants to use only patent-free technology while you would certainly object if somebody wanted you to give away the fruits of your labor free of charge. Compact Disc used to be patented (it was a nickel a disc to get rights to all the salient intellectual property rights) but those patents have since expired. However, the Philips "Compact Disc" trademark mark is still licensed as trademarks remain enforceable as long as they're still in use.
Profile Pic
Maintroll
Champion Author Lexington

Posts:11,216
Points:2,305,085
Joined:Aug 2008
Message Posted: Jan 27, 2013 8:14:25 AM

High Definition was primarily designed only for TVs, and I do not have it in my vehicle, but I have XM satellite which is stereo and very clear if you have a decent radio and stereo system in your vehicle.
Profile Pic
WEPSMAN
Champion Author South Dakota

Posts:11,306
Points:2,553,875
Joined:Mar 2005
Message Posted: Jan 26, 2013 10:03:59 PM

do not know about HD radio, but I like my XM raadio.
Profile Pic
eccerr0r
Champion Author Fort Collins

Posts:1,930
Points:1,135,760
Joined:Apr 2011
Message Posted: Jan 26, 2013 2:29:34 PM

For those not familiar with it, HD Radio is a digital signal radio broadcast along with the standard FM station, and *here's the kicker* it should be on the same frequency but different sideband. It's broadcast in compressed digital format, so interference shouldn't be an issue.

The thing about HD radio is that it's broadcast free of charge to the consumers who have an HD radio, much like how ATSC digital television is broadcast to viewers off the air which is also free to receive (unlike satellite).

I just dislike the extra royalty charge that's needed to decode the digital signals. I was tempted to try to build a HD radio receiver just to see what was out there but it seems like I need to buy a chip or license decoding information to play it... Granted this is not an issue with most listeners who would just buy an HD radio and use it.
Profile Pic
planetmail
Champion Author Calgary

Posts:9,072
Points:1,846,335
Joined:Jan 2009
Message Posted: Jan 26, 2013 1:51:48 PM

No
Profile Pic
FuelPump
Champion Author Los Angeles

Posts:24,100
Points:4,016,975
Joined:Apr 2003
Message Posted: Jan 26, 2013 12:40:17 PM

No, not to me, at least not now.
Profile Pic
Greenrancher
All-Star Author Indianapolis

Posts:923
Points:694,845
Joined:Apr 2007
Message Posted: Jan 26, 2013 12:16:32 PM

No HD, but I have Sirius/XM. I don't travel as much as I used to and don't use sat radio as much. Doubt I'd take advantage of HD either.
Profile Pic
Dale Jr.
Champion Author Illinois

Posts:18,819
Points:3,837,825
Joined:May 2004
Message Posted: Jan 26, 2013 11:50:14 AM

Never heard of it.
Profile Pic
PatAZ
Champion Author Tucson

Posts:10,120
Points:144,070
Joined:May 2008
Message Posted: Jan 26, 2013 10:27:14 AM

Don't have it and wouldn't use it.
Profile Pic
kellyoneal
Champion Author Louisville

Posts:3,102
Points:1,222,590
Joined:Mar 2011
Message Posted: Jan 26, 2013 10:20:45 AM

I do not have it
Profile Pic
toms1120
Champion Author Maryland

Posts:14,053
Points:2,400,135
Joined:Jun 2004
Message Posted: Jan 26, 2013 10:08:36 AM

Don't have it.
Profile Pic
probedude2
Champion Author Akron

Posts:15,149
Points:2,980,380
Joined:Jun 2003
Message Posted: Jan 26, 2013 1:02:49 AM

I can't get any HD stations where I live
Profile Pic
noblegiant
Champion Author Philadelphia

Posts:3,875
Points:1,462,130
Joined:Nov 2007
Message Posted: Jan 26, 2013 12:18:59 AM

Never Heard Or Tried It
Profile Pic
OceanArcher
Champion Author Mississippi

Posts:8,144
Points:1,897,525
Joined:May 2004
Message Posted: Jan 26, 2013 12:09:10 AM

HD radio does not yet impress me ...
Profile Pic
eccerr0r
Champion Author Fort Collins

Posts:1,930
Points:1,135,760
Joined:Apr 2011
Message Posted: Jan 25, 2013 10:45:21 PM

Odd, I thought that HD radio was simulcast with the FM signal - same frequency but on a sideband. Not sure however...

I really don't think it's worth it unless it's cheap, but not sure how pervasive this will end up being...
Profile Pic
14smoke
Champion Author Birmingham

Posts:14,690
Points:2,245,030
Joined:May 2005
Message Posted: Jan 25, 2013 2:11:06 PM

HD Radio does not drop back into analog, as there is no analog signal to drop back to. If the signal is not strong enough, you just get nothing, or the strongest thing on that frequency.

Is it worth it is another question entirely. I'm in the radio business and there are only about half a dozen HD stations in my city. That varies from place to place though.

If you can get a real good price on an HD Radio, might not be bad, but, I wouldn't pay a price premium just to get it.
Post a reply Back to Topics